Modeling Best Practices, Tips and Advice

Turn penalties and intersection modeling

Q-traf does not allow to set turn penalties for an intersection defined as a single point / link ends (Q-Traf algorithm can’t manage “turn penalty” tables without requiring much more RAM). Penalties can only be defined on links (Tabs “Links categories” and “Curves” in Q-Traf). To set turning penalties, it is necessary to draw each turn as a link (in the QGIS links layer) :

Base intersection4-links intersection12-links intersection
Each turn movement is a link
=> No turn penalty can be specified in Q-TrafEach turn penalty can be specified through the link category
Create and use specific “link category” for the turning movement links.
(beware that there are only 50 categories allowed)

This representation has its advantages and disadvantages :

DrawbacksAdvantages
“Turn penalty” on linksIntersections modeling is more tedious. But it is not necessary to code all intersections in detail, and the intersection pattern is always the same.Turn penalties are not stored in a separate, linked and error-prone table, but are clearly visible in the single “network” layer (and they can be drawn with a specific color).
Button_to_Top

How to model RHT and LHT ? What ‘s the difference ?

There are only 2 differences between “right-hand traffic” or “left-hand traffic” modeling :

The road network / links layer are drawn differently
Drawing link flows/data in QGIS requires an opposite offset :
– positive offset for RHT
– negative offset for LHT

=> There is no difference in the Q-Traf parameters

Button_to_Top

How to prevent unwanted U-turn ?

U-turns are possible as soon as 2 links are connected.
To avoid it :
Remove unnecessarily short links/unnecessary crossroads,
or
Separate the links in each direction (at least by a few meters as a precaution, since the coordinates are rounded to the meter)
Button_to_Top

How to model a roundabout ?

Avoid links too short for entering and exiting roundabouts ;









In the event of congestion on the ring, some of the traffic could be diverted


Use long enough entry and exit links
Button_to_Top